2009 Baltimore, MD Area Winners
| category | candidate | schoolname | showname |
| Rising Critic | Anna Bellantoni | Notre Dame | |
| Junior Critic | Kelsey Schneider | Notre Dame | |
| Senior Critic | Sarah Goldstein | Glenelg Country | |
| Critic Team | Glenelg Country | ||
| Sound | Grace Koplow | Wilde Lake | Pippin |
| Lighting | Danny Solow | Wilde Lake | Pippin |
| Sets | Margeaux Malone & Period 5 Production Company Class | Centennial | The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 |
| Costumes | Kat Schuster | Wilde Lake | Pippin |
| Make-up | Talon Zinger | Wilde Lake | Pippin |
| Props & Effects | Nara Allen, Jayde McWilliams, Madeleine Boyes | Oakland Mills | The Mousetrap |
| Stage Crew | Jenna Johnson | Centennial | The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 |
| Orchestra | The Boy Friend Pit Band | Marriotts Ridge | The Boy Friend |
| Choreography | Jilli Grabau, Rachel Whitcomb | Wilde Lake | Pippin |
| Ensemble in a Play | The Love Triangle: Mollie, Giles, and Christopher | Oakland Mills | The Mousetrap |
| Ensemble in a Musical | The Leading Players | Wilde Lake | Pippin |
| Cameo Actress | Raven Carpenter | Catonsville | The Crucible |
| Cameo Actor | Greg Kufera | Hereford | Seussical |
| Female Dancer | Jilli Grabau | Wilde Lake | Pippin |
| Male Dancer | Chris Gallant | Atholton | Footloose |
| Female Vocalist | Aria Guarino | Severna Park | The Sound of Music |
| Male Vocalist | Elijah Williamson | Wilde Lake | Pippin |
| Comic Actress in a Play | Sarah Bluher | Centennial | The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 |
| Comic Actor in a Play | Patrick Donovan | Centennial | The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 |
| Comic Actress in a Musical | Maddie Lawrence | Wilde Lake | Pippin |
| Comic Actor in a Musical | Thomas Conchie | Marriotts Ridge | The Boy Friend |
| Featured Actress in a Play | Lisa Rediker | Centennial | The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 |
| Featured Actor in a Play | Patrick Burr | Centennial | The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 |
| Featured Actress in a Musical | Maeve Ricaurte | Glenelg Country | Into the Woods |
| Featured Actor in a Musical | Antonio Beverly | Wilde Lake | Pippin |
| Lead Actress in a Play | Marci Raymond | Oakland Mills | The Mousetrap |
| Lead Actor in a Play | Josh Kudisch | Centennial | The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 |
| Lead Actress in a Musical | Nina Kauffman | Hereford | Seussical |
| Lead Actor in a Musical | Matt Summers | Reservoir | Big River |
| Song | Muddy Water | Reservoir | Big River |
| Play | The Mousetrap | Oakland Mills | The Mousetrap |
| Musical | Man of La Mancha | Loyola Blakefield | Man of La Mancha |
